STR or MTR? Model the month.
Compare a Nashville property’s nightly and furnished monthly models with assumptions you control. See revenue, operating costs, NOI, cash flow after debt, and the occupancy needed for the STR to catch up.
Step one
Set your property assumptions
Defaults are illustrative. Replace them with your own rate, costs, booking pattern, and verified tax assumptions.
Inputs stay in this browser session only.
Strategy one
Short-term rental
Nightly revenue with modeled occupancy, stay length, and turnover economics.
Strategy two
Mid-term rental
Furnished monthly revenue with occupied months and a simpler turnover cycle.
Shared property costs and tax planning
Assumptions that stay outside the winner
Debt service affects cash flow after NOI. Tax fields create separate estimates and never reduce the operating-profit comparison.
Percent fields clamp to 0–100% when you leave them. Blank and zero values are handled without NaN results.
Your comparison
The MTR model leads on modeled NOI.
Compare the revenue, cost, and cash-flow lines below before changing the property’s operation.
Nightly model
Short-term rental
191 booked nights · 74 turnovers
Annual gross rent
$46,893
Room revenue before cleaning fees.
Effective gross revenue
$53,886
After modeled vacancy, including modeled cleaning fees.
Monthly equivalent
$4,491
Effective gross revenue divided by 12.
Operating costs
$60,035
Visible below, before debt service.
NOI / operating cash flow
-$6,148
Revenue minus operating costs.
Cash flow after debt
-$6,148
NOI minus annual debt service.
Monthly model
Mid-term rental
10 occupied months · 4 turnovers
Annual gross rent
$52,000
Occupied-month rent.
Effective gross revenue
$52,000
After the occupied-month assumption.
Monthly equivalent
$4,333
Effective gross revenue divided by 12.
Operating costs
$42,780
Visible below, before debt service.
NOI / operating cash flow
$9,220
Revenue minus operating costs.
Cash flow after debt
$9,220
NOI minus annual debt service.
NOI difference, STR vs MTR
−$15,368
−167% versus MTR NOI
After-debt difference
−$15,368
Debt service is held constant for both strategies.
Annual debt service
$0
Deducted only after NOI.
Short-term rental costs
Annual operating costs included in NOI.
- Cleaning and turnover$5,300
- Platform fees$8,083
- Management fees$10,777
- Maintenance reserve$2,694
- Owner-paid utilities$3,360
- Supplies and consumables$1,020
- Fixed property costs$28,800
Mid-term rental costs
Annual operating costs included in NOI.
- Turnover costs$720
- Management fees$5,200
- Maintenance reserve$2,600
- Owner-paid utilities$3,360
- Furnishing replacement reserve$2,100
- Fixed property costs$28,800
Planning insight
STR break-even occupancy
The STR model reaches the MTR NOI at about 91% occupancy, using the assumptions above.
Modeled STR contribution: $141 per booked night after platform, management, reserve, and turnover assumptions. This compares NOI, not debt service.
Verify current treatment
Tax planning estimates stay separate
These estimates are not deducted from NOI or cash flow. Collection and remittance can depend on the booking channel, agreement length, registration, marketplace rules, and current Metro and Tennessee treatment. Confirm the exact arrangement with Metro Finance / Collections and the Tennessee Department of Revenue.
STR estimate
- Local occupancy tax$0
- Flat nightly room fee$0
- Sales tax planning estimate$0
Uses 0% local rate, 0% sales-tax rate, 1 room(s), and a $0 nightly fee.
MTR estimate
30–89 day sales tax is not modeled. Turn on the toggle only when testing a verified question.
Local occupancy tax and flat room fees are not applied to the MTR comparison by default.
Read the model
Methodology and boundaries
- ADR
- Average daily rate, the nightly room price before modeled taxes.
- Occupancy
- Booked STR nights divided by available STR nights. MTR vacancy is represented by occupied months out of 12.
- Effective gross revenue
- Modeled rent revenue after the vacancy assumption, plus cleaning fees charged in the STR model.
- NOI
- Effective gross revenue minus the operating costs shown above, before debt service.
- Cash flow after debt
- NOI minus the optional annual debt service input. Debt does not change the NOI winner.
- This excludes
- Acquisition and closing costs, one-time furnishing, income taxes, appreciation, legal or accounting fees, and any cost you do not enter.
Nashville planning note
Metro’s under-30-day STRP rules and 30+ day residential-tenancy planning are different questions. Verify the exact property’s permit, zoning, tax, insurance, lease, HOA, and lender requirements before changing how it operates.
Official source titles to review
Planning tool only. It is not legal, tax, insurance, zoning, lending, or investment advice. Rates, rules, prices, and property facts change. Verify before acting.
Keep planning
Use the numbers with the next decision.
Review the free playbook for a 30+ day pivot checklist, then use the Survival Guide for broader Nashville compliance planning.
Save your own assumptions separately. This tool does not store inputs, connect to market data, or confirm permit or tax eligibility.